Guide
What happens if your tenant challenges a rent increase
Since 1 May 2026, a tenant who thinks a proposed rent is above the open market rent can apply to the First-tier Tribunal (Property Chamber) before the start date in the Section 13 notice. For tenants it is close to risk-free: the tribunal cannot set a higher rent than the landlord proposed. For landlords, the increase waits for the decision.
The increase is on hold
While the case is with the tribunal, the tenant keeps paying the current rent. The new rent takes effect from the tribunal's decision, or from the date in your notice if the decision comes first. It is not backdated, and the tribunal can delay it by up to two months if it would cause the tenant undue hardship. In the decisions published so far, the typical time from notice to decision was about 4 months. Cases still waiting are not counted, so real waits may be longer.
What the tribunal decides
The tribunal decides the open market rent for the home on the terms of the tenancy, using the evidence both sides send and, sometimes, an inspection. It sets that rent if it is lower than yours, or confirms your figure. Under the new rules it set a lower rent in 67% of 317 decisions so far.
How to prepare
- Follow the tribunal's directions and deadlines exactly.
- Send comparable evidence: rents agreed for similar homes carry the most weight, supported by current adverts and nearby tribunal decisions.
- Describe the property honestly, with dated photos. Tribunals adjust for condition, white goods, carpets, kitchens and bathrooms.
- Keep proof that the notice was served properly.
You deal with the tribunal yourself or through a professional representative. RentProven prepares documents for landlords; it does not act for you or contact the tribunal for you.
Fewer challenges in the first place
The best challenge is the one that never happens. Talk to your tenant before the form arrives, explain how you reached the figure, and show them what similar homes are advertised for now. Your RentProven pack includes a one-page summary for your tenant, served with Form 4A, that does exactly that.
Prepared before you serve
Check your dates free, then get an evidence pack ready before you need it.
Working out the new figure first? Try the rent increase calculator.
Free tools
- Form 4A date checker: the earliest valid start date and the last day to serve.
- Rent increase calculator: the new rent, the yearly difference and the dates.
- Rent tribunal decisions near you, or by area.
More guides
- How to increase rent in England: the Section 13 notice and Form 4A
- Rent increase notice in England: what it is and what to send
- How much can a landlord increase the rent in England?
- Rent tribunal decisions since 1 May 2026: what the data shows
- Evidence for a rent increase: what tribunals give weight to
- Form 4A dates explained: two months, 52 weeks and the rent period
- How to serve a Section 13 notice, and prove you did
- How to tell your tenant about a rent increase
- Rent review clauses after 1 May 2026: what changed
- How to fill in Form 4A, question by question
- Can a tenant refuse a rent increase?
- Section 13 notice mistakes that make it invalid
- Agreeing a rent increase with your tenant since May 2026
- How long does a rent tribunal take?