Guide

Evidence for a rent increase: what tribunals give weight to

Updated 12 November 2026 · 5 minute read · England only. Information, not legal advice.

If your tenant challenges a rent increase, the tribunal decides the open market rent from the evidence in front of it. Many cases are decided with little or no evidence from either side, which leaves the tribunal to rely on its own knowledge. Good evidence, gathered before you serve, makes your figure easier to accept and easier to defend.

Rents actually agreed carry the most weight

Tribunals prefer rents that were actually agreed for comparable homes over asking prices, because adverts can be negotiated down. The Valuation Office Agency's rent officers collect agreed rents across England and publish them by area and number of bedrooms: the closest thing to agreed-rent evidence most landlords can get.

Asking rents show today's market

Current adverts for similar homes nearby show what a tenant would pay to move. Keep dated screenshots showing the rent, size and location, and note how each compares with your home. They support agreed-rent evidence rather than replace it.

Tribunal decisions nearby

Published decisions show what the tribunal has set for similar homes near you. Close matches on size, type and location are the most useful. See decisions by area.

The condition of your home

The tribunal adjusts for differences between your home and the comparables. In a sample of 150 recent decisions, it most often looked at:

  • Disrepair (89% of decisions)
  • White goods (cooker, fridge, washing machine) (77% of decisions)
  • Carpets and curtains (67% of decisions)
  • Kitchen or bathroom, modern or dated (63% of decisions)
  • Windows and glazing (59% of decisions)
  • Damp or mould (38% of decisions)

38% of those decisions put a figure on a deduction for condition, often £80 to £100 a month. Dated photos of each room, the appliances you provide and recent work answer these points before they are raised. Your Energy Performance Certificate records the floor area, glazing, heating and walls.

All of it in one pack

The RentProven evidence pack brings together VOA recorded rents, the ONS average, current asking rents, the closest tribunal decisions, your EPC, your photos and condition notes, with your figure on one chart.

Working out the new figure first? Try the rent increase calculator.

Free tools

More guides